Risk & Compliance The skinny on FICO® Scores and inquiries

May212012

One of the largest misconceptions around how the FICO® Score works involves its treatment of credit inquiries, and what happens to a score when a consumer applies for credit. In this post, I’ll answer some of the most common questions we receive on this subject, from lenders and consumers alike.

Does the FICO® Score penalize for rate shopping?
FICO® scoring models use specialized logic that accounts for rate shopping for student, auto and mortgage loans. In general, student loan, auto and mortgage-related inquiries that occur 30 days prior to scoring have no effect at all on the FICO Score. Outside this 30-day period, student loan, auto and mortgage-related inquiries that occur within any 45-day period are treated as a single inquiry. 

This inquiry logic applies to loans of the same type. In other words, if someone were shopping for a car loan and home loan during the same 45-day period time period, the auto loan inquiries would be counted as one inquiry, and the mortgage loan inquiries would be counted separately as another inquiry. This is because they represent two separate searches for credit. (Remember that all auto, mortgage, and student loan inquiries made within the last 30 days would not be counted at all.)

The best advice for consumers concerned about score impact is simply to do their rate shopping in a reasonably short period. That's easier if borrowers do their homework ahead of time to decide which companies to approach for quotes. Such planning also should make the loan rates easier to compare since the quotes will come only a few days apart.

Do all inquiries affect the score?
No, the only inquiries that count toward a FICO® Score are those that result from when a consumer actively applies for new credit. The FICO Score does NOT consider:

  • Consumer disclosure inquiries — requests made by consumers to obtain a copy of their individual credit report in order to check it.
  • Promotional inquiries — requests made by lenders in order to make pre-approved credit offers.
  • Account review inquiries — requests made by lenders to review existing accounts with them.
  • Employment inquiries — requests marked as coming from employers.
  • Insurance inquiries — requests marked as coming from insurance companies.

How much does a credit inquiry impact a FICO® Score?
In general, inquiries have a small impact; typically, a single inquiry can lower a FICO® Score by less than five points. (For more facts on inquiry impact, check out my last post.) The precise impact will vary based on each person’s unique credit history. Inquiries can have a greater impact if consumers have few accounts or a short credit history.

Among the five data categories that make up the FICO® Score, inquiry characteristics fall into the “search for new credit” category, which accounts for only 10% of the score. Since inquiries only represent one type of characteristic in this category, they actually account for less than 10% of the score. 

Why does a credit inquiry affect the score?
Research consistently demonstrates that consumers who are seeking new credit accounts are riskier than consumers who are not seeking credit. Statistically, people with six or more inquiries on their credit reports can be up to eight times more likely to declare bankruptcy than people with no inquiries on their reports. While inquiries often can play a part in assessing risk, they play a minor part. Much more important factors for the score are how timely a consumer pays bills and his/her overall debt burden as indicated on the credit report.

For more information and advice to consumers, you can direct your customers to check out the credit inquiries page on myfico.com.

5 Comments

  • Greg

    Does the shopping window for mortgages as stated above apply to Fair Issac v.2, Classic ’04 and Beacon 5.0? As those are the only one that would matter regarding getting a mortgage, I don’t care about Vantage or Nexgen.

    • Ethan

      Classic ’04 (aka FICO Score 4) and Beacon 5.0 (aka FICO Score 5) both incorporate a consistent 45 day shopping window. FICO v2 score (aka FICO Score 2) was built several years prior to FICO Score 4 and FICO Score 5. The shopping window for FICO Score 2 is 14 days.

      • Greg

        Do you work at FICO?

        Sent from my Sprint Samsung Galaxy S® 6.
        ——– Original message ——–From: Disqus Date: 10/10/16 6:58 PM (GMT-07:00) To: cocrawfords@gmail.com Subject: Re: Comment on The skinny on FICO® Scores and inquiries
        “Classic ’04 (aka FICO Score 4) and Beacon 5.0 (aka FICO Score 5) both incorporate a consistent 45 day shopping window. FICO v2 score (aka FICO Score 2) was built several years prior to FICO Score 4 and FICO Score 5. The shopping window for FICO Score 2 is 14 days.”

        Settings

        A new comment was posted on FICO

        Ethan

        Classic ’04 (aka FICO Score 4) and Beacon 5.0 (aka FICO Score 5) both incorporate a consistent 45 day shopping window. FICO v2 score (aka FICO Score 2) was built several years prior to FICO Score 4 and FICO Score 5. The shopping window for FICO Score 2 is 14 days.

        8:58 p.m., Monday Oct. 10

        |

        Other comments by Ethan

        Reply

        to Ethan

        Ethan’s comment is in reply to

        Greg:

        Does the shopping window for mortgages as stated above apply to Fair Issac v.2, Classic ’04 and Beacon 5.0? As those are the … Read more

        You’re receiving this message because you’re signed up to receive notifications about replies to disqus_cH2k8slSN1.

        You can unsubscribe
        from emails about replies to disqus_cH2k8slSN1
        by replying to this email with “unsubscribe”
        or reduce the rate with which these emails are sent by
        adjusting your notification settings.

        • Ethan

          Yes

    • Ethan

      Classic ’04 (aka FICO Score 4) and Beacon 5.0 (aka FICO Score 5) both incorporate a consistent 45 day shopping window. FICO v2 score (aka FICO Score 2) was built several years prior to FICO Score 4 and FICO Score 5. The shopping window for FICO Score 2 is 14 days.