The Role of the FICO® Score in the Mortgage Consumer Credit Risk Ecosystem
The FICO Score is a primary factor in determining consumer credit risk for mortgage originations, secondary market, and portfolio management with consumer and regulatory benefits
Applying for a mortgage is a significant event in many people’s lives, whether it’s a first-time homebuyer or a family purchasing their dream home. Yet, that is just one of the many steps throughout the mortgage lifecycle. Prior to application, lenders often work to evaluate prospective borrowers using the FICO Score through prequalification or preapproval processes. This helps streamline the loan process by determining early on whether the consumer is likely to qualify or be approved for a mortgage loan. Then, when a product offer is a good fit, the borrowers apply, but that is just the beginning of the mortgage origination process. The application then goes through underwriting, and if approved, the loan is originated. Afterwards, lenders either hold mortgages on their own books, or they sell them in the secondary market to free up capital for new loans. The secondary market plays a critical role in keeping mortgage funds flowing, and FICO® Scores are the lifeblood to this process.
FICO® Scores help standardize credit risk evaluation across lenders, geographies, and time. Investors like Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac bundle mortgages they purchase into mortgage-backed securities that they sell to secondary market investors, and the value of these securities depends on the quality of the underlying loans. Key indicators, such as loan-to-value ratios and debt-to-income ratios, are important, but the FICO Score is a primary factor in determining a loan’s credit risk profile and cash flows. Higher FICO Scores generally signal lower credit risk and more stable cash flows, while lower credit scores often indicate a higher risk of loan default though they may also signal a lower likelihood to refinance. The FICO Score at origination is often the same score used by investors and others downstream throughout the 30-year lifecycle of the loan. It is often used year after year to value, sell and repurchase the loan and its servicing rights.
When valuing mortgage-backed securities, investors are primarily concerned with cash flow predictability. Two key factors that impact cash flow are charge-offs, which occur when a borrower defaults, and prepayments, which occur when a borrower pays off the loan early. Both scenarios stop providing cash flow to the investor. FICO® Scores help predict the likelihood of these events—loans with higher FICO Scores are less likely to default, while lower credit scores can reduce the risk of prepayment but increase the risk of default.
The FICO® Score is critical to many stakeholders across the mortgage ecosystem, serving a wide range of essential functions.
In the mortgage sales and pre-origination phase, lenders use FICO® Scores for:
Prequalification: Soft pull of a FICO Score is often used to evaluate a borrower’s likelihood for qualification of a loan early in the process. This not only helps streamline the process, but it enables lenders to more effectively compete in the marketplace and to more efficiently expand the availability of mortgages by identifying more potential qualified borrowers in an efficient and cost-effective manner. It also drives efficiency by identifying unqualified borrowers upfront, benefiting both lenders and consumers by avoiding the time and cost of unnecessary applications.
Preapproval: A FICO Score, typically as a hard pull, is used by lenders early in the process as a solid basis to quickly assess a prospective borrower for loan preapproval, giving them confidence to shop for the right home from the beginning.
Product Decisioning: Borrowers are aligned with appropriate loan products based on their FICO® Scores; to help ensure they are matched with loans that are the best fit in increasing the likelihood of home ownership. Loan officers use the score to help guide potential borrowers to the best available product options, simplifying the process for the consumer and reducing potential mismatches.
Product Guideline Creation: Lenders typically define product guidelines based on credit. As a universal credit standard, FICO® Scores provide a reliable and consistent, common measure of consumer credit risk, enabling the creation of new loan product offers for consumers.
Sales Campaigns: FICO® Scores enable lenders to market more strategically, targeting brokers and potential borrowers through broker relationships and direct mail campaigns, optimizing their outreach to those more likely to qualify for loans.
In the mortgage origination phase, lenders use FICO® Scores for:
Underwriting: Following submission of the loan application, FICO® Scores are used to finalize loan terms, providing an objective measure to determine creditworthiness and ensure the mortgage loan aligns with the lender’s credit risk guidelines.
Loan Pricing: FICO® Scores allow lenders to efficiently establish and adjust loan pricing to manage risk and margins. Without a standardized credit score, consumers would face uncertainty, potentially going through the entire loan application process only to discover pricing in the final stages. FICO Scores allow for transparent, upfront pricing, giving borrowers the ability to compare offers and make informed decisions.
Insurance Pricing: Insurers rely on FICO® Scores in combination with loan-to-value ratios to set appropriate insurance premiums, ensuring that insurance costs align with the underlying risk.
In the secondary market after origination, investors use the FICO® Score for:
Mortgage-Backed Securities (MBS): Investors aggregate loans into MBS pools based on FICO® Scores, using the score to predict loan performance. This helps provide accurate valuation of these securities, which increases investor confidence and ultimately results in lower costs for consumers due to improved market liquidity.
Pooling Decisions: FICO® Scores are used to determine which loans go into specific MBS pools, ensuring that loans are grouped appropriately based on their credit risk, thereby maximizing returns for investors and driving stability for lenders, which in turn is good for consumers.
Whole Loan Sales: Investors typically will not purchase whole loans without a FICO® Score, as the score provides a benchmark to enable them to price and evaluate credit risk of such loans effectively.
Loan Loss Modeling: FICO® Scores are used to predict likelihood of default, enabling lenders to model and establish loan loss reserves more accurately. More precise reserves mean lower costs for lenders, which are passed on to consumers through lower interest rates.
Mortgage Servicing Rights (MSR): MSR valuation and sales are heavily influenced by FICO® Scores, helping servicers and investors better estimate the long-term value of servicing a loan, which also has downstream benefits for customers through more accurate servicing fees.
For portfolio management, lenders analyze FICO® Scores for:
Prepayment and Delinquency Risk: FICO® Scores help lenders monitor their portfolios for early payoffs and delinquencies, improving collection strategies and return on their investment. This active management also helps ensure the availability of more affordable lending options for consumers by reducing lender risk. For potential investors, the FICO Score is the primary factor in determining the risk profile and cash flow predictability of a loan or pool of loans—accurately identifying pre-payment and charge-off or delinquency risk is critical.
Loan Loss Reserves: FICO® Scores can be used by lenders to assess their portfolios and update loan loss reserve requirements, as appropriate. Loans with higher FICO Scores typically require lower reserves, reducing lender costs and increasing profitability, which translates to lower costs for all borrowers.
The FICO® Score also drives benefits to consumers:
Saves Borrowers Time and Money: The use of FICO® Scores across the mortgage lifecycle ultimately brings many benefits to consumers. By streamlining the prequalification and preapproval processes, it saves borrowers time and helps them quickly determine the best loan products for which a consumer qualifies.
Accurate and Competitive Pricing: Consumers can shop with confidence knowing that lenders utilizing FICO® Scores can more accurately set interest rates using a score that reflects their true credit risk profile. In the secondary market, the liquidity created by MBS pooling and loan loss modeling, driven by FICO Scores, enables lenders to offer more competitive rates and terms to borrowers.
More Money to Loan: Finally, for portfolio management, more accurate analysis can lead to lower loan loss reserves resulting in lower borrowing costs and more capital available to lend to more consumers.
The U.S. mortgage market is one of the strongest in the world, due to its unmatched liquidity and the use of the FICO® Score, which provides a standardized, reliable measure of credit risk. This combination enables efficient lending, investor confidence, and a robust secondary market, leading to lower costs for consumers, broader credit access, and a stable, transparent system that benefits lenders, borrowers, investors, and other stakeholders.
Popular Posts
Business and IT Alignment is Critical to Your AI Success
These are the five pillars that can unite business and IT goals and convert artificial intelligence into measurable value — fast
Read more
Average U.S. FICO Score at 717 as More Consumers Face Financial Headwinds
Outlier or Start of a New Credit Score Trend?
Read more
FICO® Score 10 T Decisively Beats VantageScore 4.0 on Predictability
An analysis by FICO data scientists has found that FICO Score 10 T significantly outperforms VantageScore 4.0 in mortgage origination predictive power.
Read moreTake the next step
Connect with FICO for answers to all your product and solution questions. Interested in becoming a business partner? Contact us to learn more. We look forward to hearing from you.