Increased debt load poses risk to student loan borrowers
Student loan borrowers’ increasing debt trajectory through the pandemic has been outpacing that of non-student loan borrowers
In our previous blog post on this topic, we noted how the student loan repayment pause led to disproportionately greater FICO® Score increases for student loan borrowers than non-student loan borrowers since the start of the pandemic. That’s because student loan borrowers don’t have new delinquencies on federal student loans and haven’t been required to make federal student loan repayments during the student loan forbearance period. Additionally, we noted that default rates of student loan borrowers on some non-student loan products were higher than they had been pre-pandemic – a similar trend to that observed for the rest of the U.S. population.
In this blog, we’ll focus on student loan borrowers’ pandemic-era behavior in the ‘amounts owed’ category. ‘Amounts owed’ is the 2nd most important category of the FICO Score at 30% of the score calculation. As shown in Figure 1, we observed a material decline in average scheduled monthly installment loan repayments for student loan borrowers over the first year of the pandemic. Student loan forbearance meant they no longer had to make their monthly student loan payments, which were typically in excess of $200.
Figure 1: Average scheduled monthly installment loan repayments, relative to January 2020 benchmark
However, the trajectory of growth in scheduled monthly installment loan payments has been slightly greater for student loan borrowers than non-student loan borrowers since April 2021. We’d expect the trajectory for student loan borrowers to accelerate further when student loan forbearance ends, since the Department of Education's COVID-19 student loan forbearance program ends with interest resuming on September 1, 2023, and payments restarting in October 2023. Therefore, scheduled monthly installment loan payments will suddenly increase for federal student loan borrowers.
The extent to which student loan borrowers will have to repay student loan debt will also be dependent on the Department of Education’s ability to provide targeted student loan debt forgiveness after the Supreme Court’s June 2023 decision to overturn the Department’s initial plan to eliminate student loan debt for student loan borrowers making less than $125,000 per year.
We were curious if the student loan population has broadly deleveraged on other forms of debt in anticipation of the end of the student loan payment pause, but we could not find any evidence that this is the case. Figure 2 demonstrates that the student loan population increased their auto debt slightly more than the non-student loan borrower population during the pandemic.
Figure 2: Average auto loan balances, relative to January 2020 benchmark
Both groups experienced increases in auto debt since car prices have increased since the start of the pandemic.
Student loan borrowers have also had a greater relative increase in credit card debt than non-student loan borrowers, as seen in Figure 3.
Figure 3: Average credit card balances, relative to January 2020 benchmark
Both groups were able to increase savings and substantially pay down debt in the first year of the pandemic, driven by government stimulus and reduced spending. Since then, as pandemic-related restrictions have eased, both groups have increased their discretionary spending, and by extension, their credit card debt. However, student loan borrowers have increased their credit card debt beyond their pre-pandemic benchmark, while non-student loan borrowers have not.
It’s important to note that these are aggregate trends, and that not all student loan borrowers increased debt over the last few years. Figure 4 illustrates this point: while 43% of student loan borrowers increased their total monthly installment loan payments between April 2021 and April 2023, 26% of this population decreased their monthly installment loan payments.
Figure 4: Student loan borrowers’ difference in scheduled monthly installment loan repayments between April 2021 & April 2023
Those who have decreased their scheduled monthly installment loan payments over the last 2 years by paying off debt or refinancing into lower monthly payments may be in better position to absorb the impact to their monthly debt service once the student loan payment pause ends. However, those who increased their scheduled monthly installment loan payments may be less financially prepared when student loan forbearance ends, potentially resulting in increased credit card debt or missed payments. A notable increase in credit card balances, especially if paired with a new delinquency reported on the credit file, could largely negate any improvement in the FICO® Score that the student loan borrower has experienced over the last few years.
The end of student loan forbearance means that these consumers are no longer eligible for interest-free federal payment pauses and will need to make student loan payments that they haven’t had to make in over 3 years. If the Department of Education's 12-month “on-ramp” to student loan repayment is implemented, federal student loan delinquencies would not directly impact credit scores until December 2024, since federal student loan missed payments would not appear on credit reports until then. That said, any indirect impacts from the end of student loan forbearance that cause increases in credit card balances or increased delinquency on other credit obligations could impact FICO® Scores. Ultimately, credit score impacts related to the end of the student loan payment pause will be determined by whether many student loan borrowers are prepared for the end of forbearance, as well as the scope of any policies that the Department of Education is successfully able to implement in the coming months.
Popular Posts
Average U.S. FICO® Score at 716, Indicating Improvement in Consumer Credit Behaviors Despite Pandemic
The FICO Score is a broad-based, independent standard measure of credit risk
Read more
The GSE Data Is Public. Here's What It Shows About Credit Score Modernization.
Independent Milliman analysis of GSE historical data confirms what anyone can now verify directly: FICO® Score 10T is the most predictive score.
Read more
FICO® Score High Achievers: Is Age the Only Factor?
<p>FICO’s latest research on <a href="http://www.fico.com/en/blogs/risk-compliance/us-credit-quality-rising-the-beat-goes-on/" target="_blank">national FICO® Score distribution</a> shows that US credit quality continues to trend upwards, with an increasing number of consumers scoring in the highest scores ranges. Given that, we decided it was time to refresh our study on “<a href="http://www.fico.com/en/blogs/risk-compliance/infographic-what-does-a-high-credit-scorer-look-like/" target="_blank">FICO® Score high achievers</a>,” where we examine the credit behavioural profiles of consumers with higher credit scores.</p> <p>As expected, our latest study showed that older people generally have higher scores, as has been the case in our <a href="http://www.fico.com/en/blogs/risk-compliance/age-before-beauty-credit-worthiness-before-youth/" target="_blank">past research</a>. This is largely because they have trade lines that have been open longer, which leads to higher scores (assuming the trade lines are in good standing and all other things equal). The most credit savvy among you will remember that length of credit history accounts for roughly 15% of the overall <a href="http://www.myfico.com/CreditEducation/WhatsInYourScore.aspx" target="_blank">FICO® Score calculation</a>.</p> <p>But for younger consumers, it isn’t too helpful to say, “just wait until you are 50 years old, and that will fix things!” Thus, I decided to dive deeper with our analysis, including looking at the credit behavioural characteristics of younger consumers with high FICO® Scores.</p> <p>In this analysis, I looked at credit characteristics for the two highest score bands, 750-799 and 800-850, which have about 16% and 23% of the population, respectively. I further broke this down by looking at the characteristics of the youngest 15% in each group, which occurs at age 29 for the 750-799 group and 43 for the 800-850. We used FICO<strong>®</strong> Score 9 for our analysis, and examined typical variables of the categories that go into the make-up of the score.</p> <p><a href="http://www.fico.com/en/blogs/wp-content/uploads/2016/10/FICO-Score-High-Achiever-table.png"><img class="alignnone size-full wp-image-29367" src="http://www.fico.com/en/blogs/wp-content/uploads/2016/10/FICO-Score-High-Achiever-table.png" alt="fico-score-high-achiever-table" width="715" height="747" /></a></p> <p>Since there’s a lot to dissect in this chart, I’ll highlight a few findings that struck me: <ul> <li><strong>Credit history.</strong> Higher scores are undoubtedly associated with a longer time on file. What’s striking is the higher average time on file for the 800+ group, both overall and for revolving accounts (the most common trade line). Clearly, it helps to start credit use early in life – but that’s not the sole determining factor for high scoring. The younger cohorts in both the 800+ and 750-799 groups have time on file medians significantly less than their older counterparts.</li> <li><strong>New credit.</strong> High credit scorers do, in fact, pursue new credit. We see little variation in months since last trade line opening and last inquiry among all groups observed.</li> <li><strong>Pay on time.</strong> As you might expect, the further in the past the delinquency, the higher the score – and that’s <u>if</u> a delinquency ever happened. 95% of the 800+ people and 72% of the 750-799 group have never been delinquent, which is a striking contrast to the 57% for the total population. The percentages for the younger groups are even higher, especially so for the 750-799ers. Collection items are also scarce for these high scorers. While 23% of the national population have collection items greater than $99, the figures are only 0.5% for the 800+ group and 3% for the 750-799 group. It is clear that, in conjunction with starting a credit file early, paying on time is a key trait of the FICO® Score high achiever.</li> <li><strong>Balance and utilization.</strong> Finally, we look at how credit is being used, focusing on revolving product use. (Since most people only have one mortgage or one auto loan, variation in instalment product figures is minimal and driven by payment history, which is near perfect for high scorers, as we’ve seen.) FICO® Score high achievers tend to have more open revolving accounts. While the % active trades and utilization are generally lower, by no means do high scorers avoid the use of credit products. What drives the difference here is the amount of <u>available</u> revolving credit utilized. The 800+ group is roughly 1/4 of the national median, both in total and on their highest utilized card; they also have lower balances and more cards<em>. </em>The 750-799 group is more active and higher utilized, but still only at 2/3 of the national figures. The young 750-799 group compensate with lower revolving balances and, as a result, lower utilization, which is in line with what we see for the 800+ group.</li> <li><strong>Benchmarks.</strong> I’d like to point out that while this study provides good benchmarks of the typical credit traits of the FICO® Score high achiever, individual credit profiles will vary widely. And keep in mind that when we sort groups of consumers as a whole by different behaviours, some results may look superficially odd. For example, the 800+ band has a longer median average open account time (128 months) than average revolving months on file (140 months).</li> </ul> So, what do we conclude? A huge takeaway is that high scorers don’t have too much in the way of serious delinquencies and negative public record data.</p> <p>In most respects, the young 800+ people are like their peer group. They really only differ markedly in their shorter credit history and higher non-mortgage balance, both of which are a function of life stage. Our results show that you don’t have to be a credit product hermit; these high scorers have more credit cards. The takeaway is to start credit activity early and maintain well-managed and moderate usage.</p> <p>In many ways, the young 750-799 people are more interesting because their age profile is much younger. Their credit characteristics differ more from their peer group, particularly in terms of length of credit history. They compensate by having almost pristine credit records and lower balances.</p> <p>Ultimately, 39% of US consumers are FICO® Score high achievers, which they accomplish by following common-sense credit practices. It ain’t rocket science!</p>
Read moreTake the next step
Connect with FICO for answers to all your product and solution questions. Interested in becoming a business partner? Contact us to learn more. We look forward to hearing from you.